This recipe for “Poor Man’s Prime Rib” uses a budget-friendly eye of round roast, a lean cut, which is simply seasoned and then cooked to tender goodness. Through high-temperature searing, followed by a slow, residual-heat process, this roast results in a tender, juicy interior with a flavorful crust, all without the usual prime rib pricetag. It’s ideal for a special dinner or family meal, providing a taste of prime rib on a budget!

Why You’ll Love Poor Man’s Prime Rib:

Affordable Alternative: Eye of round roast is a relatively lean and unfancy cut that, cooked correctly, becomes melt-tender in the way of a prime-rib-ish roast.

Few Ingredients, Lots of Flavor: Just a few spices make an incredibly well-seasoned crust.

Perfect for Get-Togethers: This roast is a showstopper for special occasions, but simple enough to whip up for weeknight dinners.

Juicy & Tender: The high-heat sear combined with slow cooking in residual heat means you get a juicy, tender roast every time.

Key Ingredients:

Eye of Round Roast: A very lean cut of beef perfect for roasting. Pick a roast that’s trimmed of excess fat on the outside for the most even crust.

Seasoning: Salt brings out the meat’s natural flavors, while garlic powder and onion powder add savory depth. You can add on other herbs and spices, such as rosemary or thyme, if you wish.

Oil: You may want to rub a very thin layer of olive oil on the roast, before seasoning, just to help the spices stick, but that’s optional.

Full ingredient list with quantities and instructions in the recipe card below

Would you like to save this?

Just drop your email here and I'll send it right away!

Instructions

Preheat the Oven:

Set temperature: Heat oven to 500 F (260 C). This searing temperature will give a bright, intense initial crust that sets the roast’s natural juices.

Prep the Roasting Pan: Place a roasting pan or baking dish without covering or adding any water.

Season the Roast:

Seasoning Blend: Rub salt, pepper, garlic powder, and onion powder all over eye of round roast. If desired, dice and add 1 medium fennel bulb to the roast.

Pat and Press: With your hands, lightly pat the seasoning down so it can stick; it will create a crust on the roast.

Cooking

First High-Temperature Roast:

Put in oven: This place the seasoned roast in the roasting pan once the oven is preheated.

Lower and Reduce Immediately lower the oven temperature to 475°F (245°C). Roast 21 minutes (or 7 minutes a pound), which will set a crust on the roast’s outside.

Slow Cooking:

Shut The Oven: After that initial period of searing, turn the oven off but keep the oven door closed. The sealed environment enables the roast to finish cooking slowly and evenly.

Cook in Residual Heat: Leave the roast in the oven’s residual heat for 2 1/2 hours. This is a step that requires patience, but is important for a tender juicy roast.

Resist the Urge to Peek: Opening the oven door during the slow-cooking period can drop the internal temperature significantly.

Check for Doneness:

Remove (and Check Temperature): After the 21/2-hour resting period, insert a meat thermometer into the roast to check its internal temperature. It should get to a temperature of at least 145°F (65°C) for a medium-rare doneness.

Adjust for Doneness: If you want a more done roast, you can put it back in the oven for another 30-60 minutes.

Serving

Carve the Roast:

Slice Thin: For the perfect texture and flavor, slice the roast thin. This method of slicing ensures that every serving has a bit of the seasoned crust and tender interior.

Serve: Set out roast with desired accompaniments. This technique yields a tender, juicy roast that gives prime rib a run for its money — at a (relatively) reasonable price.

Serving Suggestions:

Serve this delicious Poor Man’s Prime Rib with traditional sides and you have a complete meal. Here are some ideas:

Fourth Course: Mashed Potatoes Creamy mashed potatoes complement the rich flavors of the roast well.

Roasted vegetables: Carrots, Brussels sprouts or asparagus are great for a colorful, healthful side.

Au Jus or Horseradish Sauce: A squeeze of light au jus or tangy horseradish sauce adds flavor.

Yorkshire Pudding: A classic touch, serve with Yorkshire pudding to soak up the roast’s juices.

Storage and Reheating Tips:

Because this roast stores well, leftovers are a win!

Refrigerate: Place leftover roast in an airtight container and refrigerate it for 3 days.

Freeze: Wrap slices in plastic wrap and place in a freezer-safe container for up to 3 months. Thaw in the refrigerator, then reheat.

To reheat: For best results, place slices in a 300-degree oven until warmed through, or microwave in 30-second intervals.

Recipe Variations:

Here are some variations to suit your tastes or even add extra flavor:

Herb-Crusted Roast: Stir some dried herbs, such as rosemary, thyme or oregano, into the seasoning mixture.

Garlic and Herb Butter: Rub the roast with a combination of softened butter, garlic, fresh herbs before roasting to create a rich, herbaceous crust.

You are not hot: Add crushed red pepper flakes or smoked paprika for a little heat.

Red Wine Jus: Pour red wine and beef broth into the roasting pan, scraping up the brown bits for a straight-from-the-pan sauce that models the roast’s flavor.

Conclusion:

This Poor Man’s Prime Rib is a great way to have a treat on a budget. With its perfectly seasoned crust and juicy, tender inside, it’s a recipe you’ll want on hand for special occasions and low-key family dinners alike. Enjoy every flavorful bite!