Save This Recipe

Just drop your email here and We'll send it right away!

I can’t tell you how many times I’ve brought a pan of mac and cheese somewhere and thought, Well, surely there will be leftovers this time. And then I come home with an empty dish and somebody else’s spoon in my purse. It’s always the same story. Folks may come for the main course, but they remember the mac and cheese.

This is the kind I’ve been making for years. Not the stovetop kind you stir and serve right away, and not the fancy kind with five cheeses and a breadcrumb situation that needs a whole paragraph of explanation. Just baked, creamy, comforting mac and cheese that tastes like somebody cared enough to turn on the oven.

It’s rich without being heavy, soft in the middle, and just a little golden on top. The sort of dish that makes people slow down and go quiet for a minute while they eat. You know it’s good when the table gets quiet.

Why This One Sticks Around

I’ve tried plenty of versions over the years. Some were fine. Some were dry. Some were so cheesy they felt like a lot after three bites. This one landed right in that sweet spot.

Here’s why I keep coming back to it:

It stays creamy, even after it cools a little.
You don’t need anything strange or expensive to make it.
It travels well, which matters when you’re carrying food to a gathering.
It reheats nicely, which matters when you want lunch the next day.

And maybe the biggest reason? It just feels familiar. In a good way.

Let’s Talk Ingredients (Nothing Fancy, Promise)

The Pasta

Elbow macaroni is the old standby, and there’s no shame in that. It holds the sauce and fits nicely on a fork. Shells work too, and so does that twisty cavatappi pasta if you like a little drama in your noodles.

Just don’t cook it too long. You want it to still have a little bite, because it finishes cooking in the oven. Overcooked pasta turns soft and tired, and nobody’s asking for that.

The Cheese

Cheddar does most of the talking here. Sharp cheddar gives you that real mac and cheese flavor. Mild cheddar keeps things gentle. I usually mix them, depending on what’s in the fridge.

Mozzarella comes along for the ride to make things creamy and stretchy. It doesn’t shout, but it makes the whole dish feel softer and richer.

If you ever feel like changing it up, Monterey Jack or gouda slide in nicely. Just don’t get too carried away. Mac and cheese still needs to taste like mac and cheese.

And yes, shredding your own cheese melts better. I know it’s annoying. I complain about it every time. But it really does help.

The Milk and Eggs

Evaporated milk is what keeps everything creamy without needing heavy cream. It’s thicker, and it bakes beautifully.

The eggs? They sound a little odd if you haven’t used them in mac and cheese before, but they’re what give that soft, almost custard-like middle. Not stiff, not scrambled, just gently set.

If eggs aren’t your thing, leave them out and add a bit more milk. It’ll be softer, but still good.

The Seasoning

Just a little garlic salt in the mix and paprika on top. Nothing loud. Just enough to wake things up and give the top some color so it looks like it belongs on a table full of other dishes.

Making It (This Is the Easy Part)

Put some music on, maybe pour yourself something cold to drink, and let’s get to it.

First, the Pasta

Big pot of water. Salt it well. Cook the macaroni until just tender, then drain it and put it back in the warm pot.

Then, the Butter

Add the butter and stir it through the hot pasta until it melts. This keeps the noodles from sticking and gives everything a little head start on flavor.

It’s a small step, but it really helps.

Now the Creamy Part

In a bowl, whisk together the evaporated milk, regular milk, eggs, and garlic salt. Whisk it well so the eggs disappear into the milk.

In another bowl, mix your cheeses together so they’re ready to go.

Layering Time

Grease your baking dish and start layering:

A layer of pasta
A layer of cheese

Do that three times, ending with cheese on top. It doesn’t have to be perfect. It’s going to melt and settle anyway.

Pour the milk mixture slowly over the whole thing. Give the pan a gentle shake so it works its way down into the noodles.

Sprinkle paprika on top and admire your work for a second. It already smells good, and it’s not even baked yet.

Into the Oven

Bake at 375°F until the top looks lightly golden and the edges are bubbling. About half an hour, give or take.

Let it sit a few minutes before cutting into it. I know that’s hard. But it helps it hold together and saves your tongue.

If You Feel Like Dressing It Up a Little

Most of the time, I leave it just like this. But sometimes, depending on who I’m feeding, I’ll add a little something.

Breadcrumb topping: Panko with melted butter on top gives a nice crunch.
Bacon: Because bacon has a way of making people very happy.
Veggies: Spinach, mushrooms, or roasted peppers mix in easily.
A little heat: Jalapeños or cayenne if your crowd likes things warmer.

Just remember, you don’t have to improve everything. Sometimes simple really is best.

How It Usually Gets Served

On busy nights, it’s dinner with a salad and maybe some green beans if I’m being ambitious.

For company, it sits next to fried chicken, ribs, ham, turkey — whatever else is on the table. It never feels out of place.

And yes, people do go back for more. Even when they say they won’t.

About Those Leftovers (If You’re Lucky Enough to Have Any)

Keep leftovers in the fridge, covered, for about four days.

When you reheat it, add a splash of milk so it doesn’t dry out. Cover it if you’re using the oven, or stir it halfway through if you’re using the microwave.

You can freeze it too, wrapped up nice and tight. Thaw it overnight and warm it slowly in the oven.

And if you want to get ahead of things, you can assemble it the day before, keep it in the fridge, and bake it when you’re ready. That’s a real gift to yourself on busy days.

Frequently Asked Questions

Okay but… mine looked kind of weird when I took it out. Still tasted fine though. That normal?
Oh, absolutely normal. Baked mac and cheese isn’t always the prettiest thing right out of the oven, especially when it’s still bubbling and settling. If it tasted good, you’re doing just fine. Looks can wait, dinner can’t.

I swear it got thicker after it sat for a bit. Did I imagine that?
Nope, you didn’t imagine a thing. It always firms up as it cools, even just over ten minutes or so. Sometimes I think it’s perfect when it’s piping hot, and other times I like it better once it’s had a minute to catch its breath.

Can I admit I mixed everything instead of layering because I was tired?
You can admit it, and you are not alone. Layering just spreads the cheese around more evenly, but mixing still gets you to the same place: cheesy pasta in a baking dish. Some nights, “good enough” is more than good enough.

Why does my top sometimes get darker than I expect? Am I doing something wrong?
Not really. Ovens have moods, I swear. If the top looks done before the middle feels hot enough, just lay a piece of foil over it and keep going. Happens to me more than I’d like to admit.

I used what cheese I had and now I’m worried it won’t taste right.
Here’s the thing — as long as it’s melty cheese, you’re probably fine. The flavor might be a little different, sure, but that doesn’t mean it’s bad. Some of my favorite versions came from cleaning out the fridge and hoping for the best.

It reheated kind of stiff the next day… did I overbake it?
Maybe, but also mac and cheese just does that sometimes in the fridge. A little splash of milk and a gentle reheat usually brings it right back. And even when it’s a little firmer, it still somehow disappears, doesn’t it?

Is it strange that I like the corner pieces best?
Not strange. Correct, actually. Those slightly crispy edges with the soft middle? That’s the good stuff. If someone tells you they don’t like the corners, I don’t know… keep an eye on them.

One Last Thing Before You Go

I really believe food is one of the simplest ways we take care of each other. You make something, you set it on the table, and people feel welcome. That’s not nothing.

This mac and cheese has done a lot of quiet work in my house and at a lot of gatherings over the years. I hope it does the same for you. And if you change it, or make it your own, or pass it along to someone else, that just feels right.

If you’ve got questions, or if you just want to tell me how it turned out, I’m always here for that. Now go enjoy your dinner, and don’t forget to save yourself a corner piece. Those crispy edges? Best part of the whole pan.