Save This Recipe

Just drop your email here and We'll send it right away!

There’s just something soulful about biting into a thick, bubbly, cheesy piece of Texas toast that’s fresh out of the oven. You know what I mean, right? It’s that golden, crispy-edged slice, warm and pillowy inside, with honest-to-goodness garlic butter seeping into every nook, and a thick, gooey blanket of cheese on top. It’s pure comfort food—like those cozy family Sundays or surprise potluck moments when everyone suddenly crowds around the kitchen because something smells irresistible.

Around here, cheesy Texas toast isn’t just for pasta night. Honestly, I’ve thrown it together on many a hectic weeknight when dinner is racing against the clock (and my patience), or as a crowd-pleasing snack when teenagers appear ravenous out of nowhere. It always delivers—the kind of food that gets you a chorus of happy sighs, whether you’re serving a bowl of soup, a salad, or just that toast on its own for one of those “I need carbs now” emergencies.

Why You’ll Love It

Ready in ten minutes, start to finish. No kidding—sometimes even less if you’re in turbo mode!
The ultimate crowd-pleaser. Kids, grandparents, picky snackers… nobody can resist.
Wildly customizable. Toss in herbs, add a swirl of pesto, use whatever cheese’s in the fridge.
Perfect for soaking up soup, dunking in marinara, or just eating straight off the sheet pan (honestly, zero judgment here).

Let’s Talk Ingredients (and Swaps!)

This recipe is all about pantry staples—stuff you probably have lurking in your fridge and cupboards right now. The best part? You can absolutely play with it to make it your own.

Butter: I usually reach for unsalted because then I can control the saltiness, but hey, salted butter totally works—just ease up on the added salt later.
Garlic powder: So easy, but if you’re feeling ambitious, mince 1–2 fresh garlic cloves and mash them right into your butter for extra oomph. (Just keep an eye on fresh garlic under the broiler—it can brown in a heartbeat!)
Bread: Thick-cut “Texas toast” style white bread is the classic. Sourdough? Yes, please. French bread? Totally welcome. Really, anything with a hefty, inch-thick slice that can stand up to all that glorious topping.
Cheese: Hand-shredded mozzarella melts like a dream (skipping the bagged stuff is worth it!), but mix in sharp cheddar, provolone, Monterey Jack, or even a little pepper Jack if you’re feeling spicy. Sprinkle in some Parmesan and things start feeling downright fancy.
Italian seasoning: None in the cupboard? A good pinch of dried oregano and basil will do you just fine.
Red pepper flakes: Totally optional, but I always add some for a little tingle if I’m not sharing with the spice-averse.

If you’re running low on butter, a mix of half butter and half olive oil tastes lush and toasty. Want to make it dairy-free? Use your go-to vegan butter and cheese shreds. (I’ve made it that way for a vegan-ish friend, and you’d better believe we were still fighting over every last piece!)

How to Make Cheesy Texas Toast (Step-by-Step)

This is one of those nearly foolproof, “don’t blink or you’ll miss how fast it’s done” recipes. My one rule? Do not walk away from your broiler. Not even to answer the door—your toast deserves your undivided attention for a few minutes!

Get prepped: Preheat your broiler on high. Move your oven rack so it’s about 4–6 inches from the heat source—close enough to toast things beautifully, but not so close you get accidental charcoal art.
Mix your spread: In a small bowl, whip up a stick of softened butter with the garlic powder, a big pinch of salt, and a few grinds of black pepper. (Give your butter time to soften—spreading cold butter should be a sport, and no one wins.)
Slather the bread: Lay on a thick, even coat on both sides of every slice. This is the step where all that garlic-butter magic soaks in, so don’t skimp! Go all-in here—future you will thank you.
First broil: Set your slices buttered-side up on a big, sturdy baking sheet. Broil for about one minute—just until the edges get a golden crisp. (Every broiler is its own special beast, so seriously, peek every 10–15 seconds. Consider this your kitchen adrenaline rush!)
Flip and repeat: Turn your slices over and broil the other side for just about a minute, until lightly toasty but not blackened.
Cheese, please: Pull the baking sheet out and quickly top each slice with a generous handful of mozzarella (and your other cheese faves if you’re going wild). Sprinkle with Italian seasoning and, if you’re into that sort of thing, a few red pepper flakes.
Final broil: Pop the tray back under the broiler for another 1–2 minutes, just until the cheese is hot, bubbly, and starting to caramelize around the edges. This is torture—the whole house will smell outrageously good—but you’re so close.
Serve: Let your toast cool for a minute or two—you know that cheese is basically lava when it’s fresh from the oven—then transfer to a platter. Honestly, sometimes we just stand around the kitchen counter and start eating, no shame.

Craving a Twist? Try These Variations

Four-Cheese Adventure: Mix up your toppings with cheddar, Monterey Jack, provolone, mozzarella—every bite is a flavor surprise (I love the way the edges get golden and crisp!).
Herby Goodness: Stir a little dried parsley, thyme, or rosemary into your garlic butter for an extra layer of “wow.”
Pesto Swirl: Swap out half the butter for green, garlicky basil pesto and just watch everyone’s eyes light up.
Meaty Morsels: Top with a sprinkle of mini pepperoni, cooked bacon bits, or chopped salami before the final broil. I kid you not, my family has literally cheered at this version.
Spicy Version: Add a dash of hot sauce to the butter, or toss some finely diced jalapeños on top with the cheese. (Perfect for those nights you need a little excitement!)
Garlic Everything: Swap in roasted garlic for a mellower flavor. Mash it into the butter and just let those cozy vibes surround you.

How to Store & Reheat (Because Miraculously, You Might Have Leftovers)

Occasionally—just occasionally—a slice or two will survive the first round. If you end up with leftovers (or if you hide a piece in the fridge for a midnight treat, not that I’m giving away my secrets), let them cool completely and package them up in an airtight container. They’ll keep for up to two days, but I’d be surprised if they last that long.

When you’re ready for round two, the broiler is still your friend—just pop the toast back on a sheet and heat for a minute or two until the cheese is melty again and the edges crisp up. A toaster oven works great, too (bonus points for crunchy bottoms—my favorite part!). And if you want to freeze some slices for later? Wrap them each tightly in plastic wrap, then foil, and freeze for up to a month. Bake or broil straight from frozen—just tack on an extra minute or two, and you’re golden.

FAQs

Can I use fresh garlic instead of powder?
For sure! Go ahead and mince up 1–2 garlic cloves and mix them into your butter. Just keep a close eye under the broiler—those little fresh bits love to brown (or, well, burn) before you know it.

What bread works best?
I swear by thick, fluffy Texas toast, but anything sturdy—French bread, Italian loaf, even an indulgent sourdough—will soak up the good stuff. As long as your slices are thick enough to hold all that glorious butter and cheese, you’re set. Don’t use anything too flimsy or you’ll end up with delicious—but floppy—toast.

Can I make it ahead?
Yep! You can slather the garlic-butter mixture onto your slices up to four hours ahead and keep them covered in the fridge. When you’re ready, simply broil, top with cheese, and finish under the broiler. That way, you can be a total rock star when guests drop in (or when the dinner hour sneaks up on you…again).

Is there a dairy-free option?
There sure is! Use your favorite plant-based butter and nondairy cheese shreds. They melt a bit differently (sometimes with a little less stretch), but it’s still every bit as craveable. In my experience, nobody at the table even guesses there’s no real cheese in the mix!

Conclusion

So that’s the magic of cheesy Texas toast in all its crusty, buttery, garlicky, oozy-cheese glory. It’s ridiculously easy, wildly adaptable, and honestly impossible not to love—even if you’re only making it for yourself. Drop your favorite twists or questions in the comments below—whether you’re pairing this with soup, salad, or just sneaking a late-night bite, I hope this toast brings big comfort and joy to your kitchen the way it does mine. Go ahead, treat yourself—you deserve every last kaboom of flavor!